Katanya payah nak cari. Disuruh saya berikan link. Saya lihat dia membalas melalui 'web' - meaning dia pakai desktop or laptop. I was apalled. Laaaa... kita pulak yang disuruh beri link. Kan page dia yang punya? Don't you think it's annoying when people ask you to give the link to YOUR photo that have been infringed? Yes. That's how I felt.
Bila berkata-kata, selalu ending dengan bahasa Arab. Syukran, Inna Allah ma'ana.
What if non-Muslims read this? Would they portray Islam is full of bad guys?
Setelah reply beberapa kali, katanya mintak halal. Ya, saya takde masalah pun nak halalkan but then I already mentioned that the manuals are for non profit usage and the page's name end is "Biz". Isn't it obvious? Katanya jugak untuk perkongsian saham akhirat. Kalau saham akhirat jual makanan sunnah - pada saya. Dan perkongsian boleh dilakukan di akaun peribadi Facebook.
Nak cakap banyak pun tak guna. At the end of the conversation, saya tulis:
الغاية لا تبرر الطريقة
"Matlamat tidak menghalalkan cara. Untuk peringatan bersama."
Saya tak berniat nak malukan empunya page. Sebab tu saya tak pamerkan nama page tu. Tapi nampak tak jawapan yang diberi? Sebagai orang yang menjadikan Bahasa Arab part of the conversation, saya anggap orang ini terpelajar. Namun cara jawapan tu, saya rasa "Eh busy sangat ke sampai tak tercari gambar?".
Jadi, buat admin page(s) di luar sana, perkasakanlah ilmu berkenaan hakcipta juga. Bukan sekadar 'sharing is caring'. You may collect profit(s) from your sharing(s), but is your profit halal?
Think about it.
P/s : I gave this entry a whole lot of thought before publishing it. I do not intend to put the person to shame but as a reminder for all of us. Rezeki Allah itu luas tapi cara untuk mendapatkan rezeki itu berbalik pada diri sendiri.
Alhamdulillah 'ala kulli haal.
Jadi, buat admin page(s) di luar sana, perkasakanlah ilmu berkenaan hakcipta juga. Bukan sekadar 'sharing is caring'. You may collect profit(s) from your sharing(s), but is your profit halal?
Think about it.
P/s : I gave this entry a whole lot of thought before publishing it. I do not intend to put the person to shame but as a reminder for all of us. Rezeki Allah itu luas tapi cara untuk mendapatkan rezeki itu berbalik pada diri sendiri.
Alhamdulillah 'ala kulli haal.
7 comments:
memang banyak saya jumpa manual tu especially seller sh****e guna.even dah ada your copyright pun dorang still letak watermark dorang cross atas satu page manual tu.nanti kalau saya ada terjumpa lagi sy mention.
thank you salma. in creative world ni, kitaje tau betapa susah nak jaga IP. diorang semedang je suka hati ambik.
although i', a bit malu la kan i takde degree in design like you heheheh~
sharing is only caring when there is a mutual feeling that such caring can be made.
what is so difficult to understand about copyrights? i am completely baffled by this and to a point, i think i am equally annoyed as you.
the point is not about sharing. the point is that, you shared something which is not yours. and the fact is that, you made it as though it is yours. and THAT, my friend, is very annoying. on top of that, you sells stuff for instance, supplements, which could be misleading to the manuals that my friend here drew from scratch. read: supplements to have more milk and reasons to buy the supplements.
(you, in this context, refers to whoever plagiarised your work, niha)
dahlah buat salah, lepas tu it sounded from the messages macam... hey, all i did was just sharing! what's wrong wif that? then nak cakap pasal syurga bladibla. come on lah.
should sue them.
tu la kak mala. i was totally at my wits end typing the message. geram gila.
people, they don't know how it feels until theirs is taken and being done the same.
siap tanya lagi apesal tak boleh. ehhh... i already mentioned not for commercial purposes. dia ingat commercial ni iklan je ke?
pfftttt...
Alahai…orang macam ni pun ada…”hendak seribu daya,tak nak seribu dalih”...orang dh baik hati perah otak nak share ilmu..tup tap ada pulak yang ambil kesempatan…..kalau saya kat tempat niha pun mesti hangin gak…
aini,
diorang ni jenis share je pastu tak tau apa. ilmu pun ada cara nak sebarkan. hadith pun mention siapa perawi untuk menentukan kesahihan.
penat layan diorang ni huhuhuhuhu~
wallaweh... aku rasa kan niha, ko bleh start buat iklan la - kepada yg memerlukan manual penyusuan susu ibu, sila kol saya utk sediakan kpd anda. bayaran akan dikenakan mengikut hasil kerja. aku jamin xde yg berminat, hahaha... innallah ha maana... 'NA' tu refers to whom? hadoi... keep on searching sista... ;)
Post a Comment